Skip to main content

Mangione’s attorneys discussed possible plea deal but talks fell apart, sources say

▶ Watch Video: Luigi Mangione’s attorneys call report of possible plea deal “troubling”

Defense attorneys for Luigi Mangione, facing charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, and federal prosecutors in New York discussed a possible plea deal in the case ahead of a hearing Monday, but talks fell apart, according to two sources familiar with the matter.  

It is unclear how close the two sides came to a possible plea agreement before negotiations ended, according to the sources. It is unknown whether there will be an effort to resume discussions. 

The pretrial hearing in the case scheduled for Monday in Manhattan federal court is still expected to take place to discuss plans for an upcoming trial.

Mangione is facing both state and federal charges for Thompson’s murder in December 2024. He has pleaded not guilty in both cases.

A spokesman for the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York declined to comment to CBS News on the plea negotiations. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg also declined to comment.

NBC News New York first reported Thursday that Mangione’s attorneys had talks with federal prosecutors about a possible plea deal in advance of the scheduled court hearing on Monday, July 6, citing sources familiar with the matter.

Mangione’s attorneys had said in a statement to CBS News earlier Thursday that the report was “troubling.”

“This information attributed to ‘anonymous sources’ is part of a troubling, deliberate pattern by prosecutors and law enforcement to prejudice Luigi, manipulate public opinion, and violate his constitutional right to a fair trial and impartial jury,” defense attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo said. “Every defendant in America is presumed innocent until proven guilty, including Luigi, who has to fight the same charges twice.”

Discussions between prosecutors and defense attorneys prior to trial, including discussions about plea agreements, are common, legal experts told CBS News.

“They’re going to have a conversation about whether or not they will do a deal. It is not at all uncommon to have a conversation about a potential plea deal throughout the process,” CBS News legal analyst Jessica Levinson said.

“Generally, the defense will say, ‘Hey, can we plead this out,’ and prosecutors will say, ‘Here’s what we can offer,'” said former Palm Beach County State Attorney Dave Aronberg.

Plea agreements can be negotiated all the way up until trial, as in the recent case of Bryan Kohberger, who pleaded guilty last July to the murders of four University of Idaho students as part of a plea deal that spared him from facing the death penalty.

“To paraphrase Lenny Bruce, ‘In the halls of justice, justice is often done in the halls,'” Aronberg said.

Earlier this month, Mangione’s attorneys said they might seek a psychiatric defense for Mangione in his New York state trial. The following day, on June 18, Mangione’s attorneys abruptly withdrew the notice of their intent to argue an “extreme emotional disturbance.”

Mangione’s case has garnered outsized attention from around the world since he was accused of the December 2024 killing of Thompson outside a healthcare industry conference in Midtown Manhattan. 

The trial in the state case is set to begin in September, followed by the federal interstate stalking trial scheduled to begin in November. 

Trump will need China for his new economic war against Iran. Good luck getting Xi on side

By CNN
Beijing (CNN) — When US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent unveiled “Operation Economic Outcast,” threatening damaging new sanctions on countries that refuse to stop doing business with Iran, he didn’t name the one country that could decide its success or failure: China.The world’s second largest economy has long been a critical economic lifeline for Tehran, buying up the vast majority of its oil exports – worth an estimated tens of billions in US dollars last year – in addition to other trade.Bringing it on board with the White House’s latest effort to subdue an Iranian leadership stubbornly defiant after almost six months of war, however, is an extremely tall order.Beijing flatly rejects what it calls “unilateral” US sanctions and has long defended its right to regular trade with partners like Iran and Russia. It also surmises that Washington would be wary of triggering a broader economic confrontation that would hurt both countries, right ahead of the US midterms.On Tuesday, following Bessent’s presser, China’s Foreign Ministry vowed to “take all necessary measures” to safeguard its “own legitimate rights and interests” in the face of US sanctions threats.“Economic warfare and maximum pressure will not help resolve the issue; they will only further intensify tensions and conflicts, create spillover risks, disrupt the global economic and financial order,” ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said.Bessent’s threat also comes ahead of a highly anticipated visit by Chinese leader Xi Jinping to the US next month, where the two sides could make progress on extending a critical trade truce set to expire later this fall.Trump earlier said that he did not ask Xi “for any favors” on Iran during a May meeting between the two – a statement, which, if correct, will likely smell to Beijing of American desperation to end the conflict.What’s left now is a careful calculus for both countries in how they navigate what Bessent has said will be a period of “quiet diplomacy” – or privately issuing ultimatums to Iran’s economic partners, which the Treasury chief did not specifically name during his press conference.Chinese analysts suggest limited space for Washington’s demands: “China is unlikely to accept a situation in which Washington determines what Chinese companies can legally trade with third countries,” said Zhao Long, director of the Institute for International Strategic and Security Studies at the Shanghai Institutes for International Studies.“That would establish a precedent that US secondary sanctions can effectively determine China’s commercial relations with third countries,” he said.What Washington could doChina imports Iranian oil using a shadowy system that’s by design insulated from the US dollar system – and sanctions.Private, so-called teapot refineries, purchase and process US-sanctioned Iranian crude, relying on a network of ports, financial institutions and tankers that are often similarly firewalled from international exposure. China hasn’t recorded these purchases officially in years, since after the US re-imposed sanctions on Iran when the first Trump administration backed out of the Obama-era Iranian nuclear deal.But pressure points do exist, analysts say.“When you look at the upstream ownership of these entities, you’ll find many are directly or indirectly held by major Chinese state-owned entities that are heavily integrated into the US dollar system,” said Max Meizlish, a senior research analyst at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies think tank in Washington.“By sanctioning their subsidiaries, the US can apply pressure on the parents to divest at risk of being deemed as providing direct or indirect support to sanctioned entities,” he said.Bessent earlier this year said Washington has sent warnings to two unnamed Chinese banks about their role in Iran-linked transactions. When asked on Monday during his press conference what measures the US would take against non-compliant Chinese banks and shipping firms, he said “no one is above” facing US sanctions.Despite the tough talk, Beijing has seen the US threaten – and then back off – sweeping sanctions before. And it also knows Washington is acutely aware of China’s significant economic leverage over the US, especially in the form of its grip on the global supply of strategically critical rare earths.“If Washington crossed that threshold (of sanctioning major Chinese banks), Beijing would almost certainly respond, and the political atmosphere for a summit (between Trump and Xi) would deteriorate sharply,” said Sun Chenghao, a senior fellow at Tsinghua University’s Center for International Security and Strategy in Beijing.Such a move might not automatically cancel their meeting, but it would “shift the summit from stabilization toward damage control,” he said.Summit considerationsBoth sides will be weighing up the impact of escalation to that summit, expected to be the first state visit by Xi to the US in 11 years.While Beijing will not want to be seen to be cooperating with a sanctions regime it opposes, there are careful maneuvers it could take – such as quietly reducing oil purchases or elevating its political messaging to Tehran and efforts to encourage restraint.Chinese purchases of Iranian oil have already declined sharply compared to last year as the US blockade has constrained Iranian crude exports.Chinese analysts have also in recent weeks suggested there are overlaps between the interests of Washington and Beijing, especially in terms of seeing trade flows restored in the Strait of Hormuz, which has been choked by the conflict, and restoring broader regional stability, also conductive to trade.And Beijing has in recent days re-upped its messaging urging restraint and normal operations around the Strait.In a joint statement following a meeting with Jordanian King Abdullah II in Beijing on Monday, Xi called for the restoration of “normal passage” through the Strait and a “comprehensive solution” to the conflict.Chinese Vice Foreign Minister Miao Deyu said last week while hosting Iranian officials in Beijing that China was “actively committed to promoting peace talks.”Even still, Beijing has shown itself wary of playing a direct mediator role in the conflict, preferring a position where it protects its own economic interests – and plays up its image as a stable power that supports regional peace, in contrast to Washington’s vacillations.Any cooperation with the US in restoring regional peace “should not be reduced to ‘doing Trump a favor,’” said Zhao in Shanghai.“Beijing is willing to contribute to ending the crisis, but it is not willing to become an instrument of Washington’s maximum-pressure strategy.”The-CNN-Wire™ & © 2026 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.
Read Next Story

Related Stories

Latest News
La huella de Dolly Parton en los artistas latinos
1 hour ago

La huella de Dolly Parton en los artistas latinos

Cnn L19jb21wb25lbnRzL2ltYWdlL2luc3RhbmNlcy9jbXQ5ZzVjbmMwMDFiM2I2cmsxY2R6NW0z L19jb21wb25lbnRzL2FydGljbGUvaW5zdGFuY2VzL2NtdDllZ3lmdDAwMXIyOXA0Nzh0dzRsMHY=

Trump gets a much-needed South Carolina win and other takeaways from Tuesday’s elections

Darline Graham ganará la segunda vuelta por el escaño en el Senado de su difunto hermano en Carolina del Sur, proyecta CNN

3 funcionarios del Servicio Secreto son puestos en licencia administrativa por presunta conducta indebida

Dolly Parton, la mujer que logró unir a presidentes, creyentes y drag queens